Warning: Cannot modify header information - headers already sent by (output started at /home/content/85/8979285/html/wp-includes/post-thumbnail-template.php:1) in /home/content/85/8979285/html/wp-content/plugins/wp-super-cache/wp-cache-phase2.php on line 62
“grading The ‘boys” (Single Games) | The DC Times - Part 2

The DC Times

A New Way to Look at the Cowboys, NFL, and Fantasy Football


“Grading the ‘Boys”: Preseason Week Two, Cowboys vs. Raiders

Jonathan Bales

My film study of the Oakland game is complete.  Thus far, I have posted my initial game reactions, things we learned from the contest, and final film study observations.

In my first “Grading the ‘Boys” from the Bengals game, I explained that it would be impossible for me to study every player as closely as I deem necessary for grading.  Instead, I watch a select group of players in great detail and report back to you on their performance.

WR Miles Austin:  A

Made a highlight catch and even got action on an end-around

NT Josh Brent: A-

Motor is second to none; I personally guarantee he makes this team

OT Robert Brewster: D-

Yielded another sack and looks over-matched at both left and right tackle

OG Travis Bright: D

Play must make Dallas extremely nervous about backup guard situation

LB Keith Brooking: A-

Lined up on tight end Zach Miller out wide and blanketed him

K David Buehler: A+

Looked sensational on field goals and kickoffs; struck the ball really well on all kicks

OLB Victor Butler: B

A small dip in production from Cincy game, but still solid outing

RT Marc Colombo: F

Gave up two sacks and didn’t dominate in run game

RB Herb Donaldson: C

Didn’t do much “wrong,” but lacks explosiveness

TE DajLeon Farr: B

Signed two days prior to game and no noticeable mental errors

LT Doug Free: C

Let Jon Kitna get sacked (although Kitna could have stepped up); must be more consistent

DE Jason Hatcher: B+

Really nice game after Stephen Bowen stood out against the Bengals

WR Jesse Holley: B

Stood out on special teams; always near the ball-carrier

LB Bradie James: A

All over the field, particularly against the pass

WR Manuel Johnson: D

Dropped pass led to pick-six in crucial situation

QB Jon Kitna: B

Getting flack, but did a fine job; made great audible to hit Sam Hurd on 32-yard pass

P Mat McBriar: A

So under-appreciated

CB Bryan McCann: B

Still shows poor technique at times, but looks natural in coverage; solid job on returns

QB Stephen McGee: C-

Leaves pocket too early; fails to hit check down in time; looks to be “thinking” too much

WR Kevin Ogletree: D

Two drops and poor field awareness once again

QB Tony Romo: C

Poor outing for Romo; held onto ball too long and missed a few open receivers

CB Orlando Scandrick: A

Has been Cowboys’ best cornerback through two games

NT Junior Siavii: B+

Showed toughness and plays the run nicely

CB Jamar Wall: C-

Can only play certain routes well; no way he makes 53-man roster in my opinion

LB Jason Williams: B+

Ironically flourishing in run support, but played pass better than Week One

LB Leon Williams: B+

Outplaying Steve Octavien and Curtis Johnson right now for roster spot

WR Roy Williams: C

Blanketed all night, but did face Nnamdi Asomugha


“Grading the ‘Boys”: Preseason Week 1, Cowboys vs. Bengals

Jonathan Bales

After reviewing the Hall of Fame game film so many times that I can literally name the play calls in order, I figured enough was enough.  Even after all of that, it is still impossible for me to watch every play for every player on the field.  With 11 players and 150+ plays a game, I would need to watch the film at least 1,650 times.  The problem is I can’t seem to crack the 1,640 barrier.

Instead of paying half-assed (is that a word?) attention to all of the players, I concentrate on certain players and report back on their play.  Below are the grades for those players to which I paid particularly close attention.

Preseason Week 1 Final Player Grades

LT Alex Barron: D

Repeatedly beat off the edge due to poor footwork; injured ankle and may not play Thursday

DE Stephen Bowen: A

Displayed incredible burst on pass rush; never stopped despite decent amount of reps

DT Josh Brent: B

Really impressive motor; consistent play will land him roster spot

RT Robert Brewster: D

Grade of “C” for his play at right tackle and “F” for left tackle; Cowboys could slide him to guard

G/C Travis Bright: C-

On a lot of 53-man roster projections but slow off the ball Sunday night

K David Buehler: C

Great kickoffs as usual, but shaky on field goals and extra point despite going three-of-four

OLB Victor Butler: A

Best game he’s played as a pro; biggest surprise was his superb run defense

RB Tashard Choice: C-

Ran hard, but struggled mightily in pass protection; too good of a player to not rebound quickly

RB Herb Donaldson:  D+

Showed burst and good vision on one run but looked tentative on others; lost a fumble

LT Doug Free: A

Perhaps most important game for any player; displayed tremendous footwork and even good strength in run game

FB Chris Gronkowski: C-

Missed quite a few blocks; long way to go to catch Deon Anderson

WR Jesse Holley: C

Up and down night; bad block in the back and poor field awareness at times, but made a few nice catches

QB Jon Kitna: B-

Played fairly well behind porous second-string offensive line; good job of checking down

QB Stephen McGee: B+

Surprised by quickness and arm strength; needs to work on pocket awareness and hitting underneath receivers

G Pat McQuistan: D-

Beat almost every play by Bengals DT Geno Atkins; would be shocked if he made the team

RB Lonyae Miller: B-

Impressive hands and route running; hard runner, but must make first guy miss

WR Kevin Ogletree: D+

Very poor field awareness; failed to drag feet once and caught another ball short of first down marker

TE John Phillips: A

Biggest heartbreak of the week; blocked incredibly well and obviously caught ball well before going down with ACL tear

QB Tony Romo: B

Missed a few throws, but overall solid night; good back shoulder throw; may call more audibles this season

TE Scott Sicko: B

“A-” grade for receiving but “C-” for blocking; obvious downgrade from Phillips but has potential

G Mike Tepper: D

Can’t see any way he makes the team

CB Jamar Wall: D-

Really struggled in both coverage and special teams; not bad versus the run, but won’t matter if he doesn’t improve coverage

OLB Brandon Williams: B+

Looks like Ware at times; good awareness on interception

LB Leon Williams: B

Great form tackling; a little weak in coverage

WR Roy Williams: B+

Good quickness out of breaks; used on “in-breaking” routes on which he excels

CB Teddy Williams: B

Shockingly good technique and overall play from track star who hasn’t played football in five years